The Village Idiom

too good to be true

The idiom "too good to be true" means that something appears to be extremely good or favorable, but it is unlikely to be real or genuine.

Filed under T

In a sentence

  • When I saw the advertisement for a brand new car at half the price, I thought it was too good to be true.
  • She couldn't believe her luck when she won the lottery on her first try; it felt like a dream come true, but also too good to be true.
  • He was skeptical when he received an email promising him a million dollars if he simply provided his bank account information; it seemed too good to be true.

Where it comes from and how it is used

One of the most commonly used idioms in the English language is "too good to be true". This phrase suggests skepticism or doubt towards something that appears exceptionally appealing. It cautions against blind trust or naivety and encourages individuals to approach things with critical thinking. The idiom is often used in situations that seem too perfect or situations in which someone is overly optimistic.

The idiom "too good to be true" has been used in written English since at least the early 19th century, indicating its longevity and relevance. Its exact origins are uncertain, but it is speculated that the phrase may have evolved from earlier sayings or proverbs with similar meanings. Regardless of its origin, the idiom's enduring usage demonstrates its significance among English speakers.

Idioms like "too good to be true" reflect the values, beliefs, and experiences of a particular culture or society. They reveal a universal tendency to approach exceptional circumstances with skepticism. This reflects the shared human experience of disappointment or disbelief when a seemingly perfect situation turns out to be unreal or unattainable.

There are several related idioms that are often used in conjunction with "too good to be true". One such idiom is "too good for this world". This expression is used to describe someone or something that is exceptionally kind, pure, or noble. It suggests that the person or thing is too good to exist in a flawed or imperfect world. While this idiom is related to "too good to be true", it emphasizes the inherent goodness or exceptional qualities of an individual or thing.

The idiom "the moon on a stick" is also related to "too good to be true". It is used to describe something that is highly unrealistic or impossible to obtain. It suggests that the desired outcome or situation is so far-fetched that it is comparable to obtaining the moon on a stick. When used alongside "too good to be true", it emphasizes the unattainable nature of something that appears excessively perfect or favorable.

"That ever walked on two legs" is another related idiom to "too good to be true". It is used to describe someone who is exceptional or outstanding in some way. The phrase suggests that the person possesses qualities or abilities that surpass what is typically considered possible or realistic for a human being. When used together with "too good to be true", it adds to the overall notion of skepticism towards something that appears exceptionally desirable.

The final related idiom is "go too far". This expression is used to describe a situation where someone exceeds the limits of what is considered acceptable or reasonable. It suggests that the person has gone beyond what is expected or appropriate. When combined with "too good to be true", it emphasizes the idea that something that appears excessively perfect or desirable may actually be crossing the boundaries of reality or practicality.

Know an earlier use or a better origin story?Tell us.